Vine Vs Instagram – Who Will Come Out On Top?
Marketing Land have used analytical tool Topsy to determine the amount of Vines compared to the amount of Instagrams shared on Twitter, and the results show what appears to be a significant loss of users for Vine.
Interestingly, the report did not show a great rise in Instagram links shared, despite the apparent huge fall in Vine shares.
This report however, was quickly met with questioning from various online sources, suggesting the Topsy analysis may not be the most accurate way to determine how many videos where shared from each service.
Mike Isaac of All Things Digital wrote that “Marketing Land’s initial measurement method was flawed, insofar as the author’s graph only showed tweets and influential people, while presenting it as a representation of Twitter links as a whole”, suggesting that as the data was not a complete representation, it could not show a truthful insight.
Perhaps in reaction to Instagram‘s new video feature, the Vine have team posted a blog last week promising the release of some “exciting new parts of Vine” within the next few weeks. The new features cold push Vine back to the social-video-sharing top spot, if it has in fact slipped due to Instagram’s success.